Well, I definitly liked the book better...shocker right?
Things I loved:
-Channing Tatum. He was really really good! I thought he was totally hot and he is a genuinly good actor. I especially liked the seen when he kept saying that he didnt know what to do (refering to reup or not). And the scene when he read the letter to his dad made me cry. :(
-The ending! Soooo glad that they changed it and Tim died. (Sry Tim!)
-The whole thing looked good put together and the characters fit.
-The explanation of why he basically had to join the army after 911. In the book I was kind of mad at him for rejoining, but the movie made it seem like he actually didn't have a choice.
-Most of the minor characters did a good job, like Savannah's dad and Tim was a good actor.
-I liked all of the army scenes. I thought they were kind of cool and it was neat to see John in that enviornment as well.
Things I didn't like:
-That Savannah left him. (I know it is in the book, but I will never forgive her!!!)
-Tim was old. REALLY old! And why in the world did they have to make Alan his son? It just made him too old for her!
-I didn't really like the very beginning, like the first two scenes. The acting wasn't that great.
I might add more later, but I have to go to dance right now so tata!