Who Wore It Better: Victoria Beckham or Alicia Keys

Both Alicia Keys and Victoria Beckham were spotted in a black button-down silk and wool dress from Victoria Beckham's Fall 2012 collection. Victoria wore a pair of open-toe black boots and accessorized with a black clutch and gold watch. Alicia wore a pair of cap-toed heels and bright pink lipstick. Who do you think wore this dress best?
 
#whoworeitbetter