I wasn't crazy about the ON version because of the zippers, so I believe I will order this one. Thanks for all the input. I was hoping to try on at my B&M but they have never gotten it in. I'll try to get up to the outlet, but if not I'll just order.
Sorry for the late response but I thought I'd chime in too! I have this J.Crew jacket in the mossy brown color (love it) and I just purchased the Old Navy one in the black- it's definitely a GREAT knock-off of this one! If I wouldn't of already had the J.crew one in the brown I totally would have purchased the ON one in that color as well. You really can't go wrong with either. Anyway, did you end up getting this one? :)